> > > Re:DNA Testing


Genealogy Message Board

Re:DNA Testing Click to ReplyReply 
  Author: Robert Burns   Date: Oct 24, 7:40 PM
  In Reply To: DNA Testing  by: paul

I took a DNA test years ago, 1980s, and what I found out is that the results are quite misleading.

I also just received my DNA results from Ancestry, with the same results. They actually reported my Grandnephew as my second cousin. The only thing I got from Ancestry was that my family is from Kerry Co, Ireland. Through my research I figured out that they were from that area. Most of the info received was obtained from my family tree on Ancestry.

Remember, the results are based on the number of people that have actually supplied DNA in each country, so if 500 people in Ireland supplied DNA and 5000 supplied DNA in England, the results will probably give you a higher percentage of matches in England even though your family may have originated in Ireland. So you can't say "Yea I'm English". You're really Irish.

Remember, the migration of people has a lot to do with your results also. If your family originates in Ireland and the majority migrates to England and prospers there but the remaining Irish dwindle, your results will show you're English when in fact you are Irish.

So your results do not show you your original nationality only where the majority of your DNA now lives.

Also out of the hundreds of possible relatives they found for me, only one had a last name of Burns.

Don't get me wrong, Ancestry is worth joining if only for their research data and search tools, but the DNA...Not worth the $100



 
Home |  Join Now |  Features |  Family Tree Sites |  Charts |  Search |  Help |  Feedback |  Privacy